Couldn't find a thread on Rinconcito Mexicano (307 W. 39). R.M. had received some positive press a few years back. Any Hell's Kitchen-ers or others been there recently? Is it still open, still really cheap (and still good)?
As unconventional as it may sound, this unlikely flavor combination is one for the books. Tangy-sweet bread and butter pickle juice against a salty peanut butter topping makes for a an incredibly rich, balanced ice cream-eating experience.