I am new to the area and have tried some of the recommendations listed on this board. Here's how I have fared:
Foto's Pizza: Great pie, highly recommend.
Poppies Deli: My pastrami sandwich was half pastrami, half fat... do not recommend.
Mario's Tuscan Grill: Higly recommend, some of the best Italian food that I have ever had.
Flakowitz Bagel Inn: Great bagels, very reasonable prices.
Max's Grill: Consistently good, great people watching.
Unfortunately I have found that many of the seafood restaurants are closed for September, but I will review them when I get a chance.