Putting together a gift case of champagne


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Wine 8

Putting together a gift case of champagne

carbonara | Jan 28, 2008 11:57 AM

After reading through a number of CH threads on champagnes, I've started planning the contents of a mixed case of champagne as a Valentine's Day present for my fiance. I tried to veer towards lesser-known and grower champagnes, though that wasn't an absolute rule. Any thoughts, critiques, and suggestions of substitutions would be highly welcome. Here are the guidelines:

- I'm hoping to spend around or less than $300 total
- As for tastes, he's very (very) (extremely) fond of Krug, particularly the heavenly '90, strongly dislikes Veuve Clicquot yellow label, likes NV Billecart and Dom a lot, and is never averse to drinking NV Feuillate and Bollinger
- Given the passion for Krug, I'm wondering if I should head toward more "muscular" champagnes, though not entirely sure which champagnes qualify. It's funny, though, because, when drinking the '90, the word muscular never comes to mind--maybe because it gets overcrowded by other words, or non-words, like "oh, my God" and "mmmm"
- I can buy the champagne in either NYC or in SF (we go back and forth a lot), though it would be great to find everything at one wine store (so far, K&L looks like a leader), and would rather not buy online, given the cold these days

Thanks in advance.

Leading contenders, for a total of ~$285 before tax:

Pierre Peters 1999 Cuvée Spéciale ($70)
Billecart-Salmon Brut Reserve ($40)
Charles Heidsieck Brut Reserve ($30)
Michel Arnould & Fils Reserve Brut Grand Cru ($35)
Franck Bonville Cuvee Les Belles Voyes Champagne ($65)
Gosset Grand Reserve ($45)

Other possibilities:

Vilmart & Compagnie Grand Cellier ($50)
Pierre Peters Cuvée de Réserve Brut N.V. ($35)
1995 Charles Heidsieck Blanc de Millénaires ($85)
Jacquesson Brut ($40)
Duval-Leroy ($30)
1996 Duval-Leory ($45)

Edited to add: Or, heck, maybe I should scrap everything and get the boy a bottle of the '96 Salon. But we've never had any Salon, ever. So would he even like it? Decisions, decisions!

Another or: maybe I should look for more '96 options among the grower champagnes.

Other CH links that have been helpful:

Gift of champagne:
True champagne: incomparable:
Affordable and versatile sparkling wines:
Mixed case of champagne:

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound