+
Home Cooking

Had a potato au gratin failure...need some pointers to fix it!

Heidi cooks and bakes | Jun 23, 201408:11 AM     41

Last night I made my first potato gratin. Here's what I did, and I need some critique to figure out where I went wrong.

Started out with old russet potatoes that were stored in the fridge. In the morning I used my mandoline and cut them into 1/8" slices. Stored them in cold water until 6 p.m.

Drained them, and patted dry with paper towels. Layered half in the dish, added 1 cup half and half. Layered Gruyere cheese and parmigiana reggiono, added potatoes, cheeses and final cup of half and half.

Baked covered for 1 hour at 350. Removed the top, and baked for 15 minutes at 415 degrees. Checked for doneness, and it was not tender. So I lowered the temperature back to 350 and baked for 30 minutes more with the top off. And though I started with the dish half full of liquid, now it was literally almost overflowing with liquid. When I took it out, it was still not as tender as I would have liked.

I served them anyway (it was now 8 p.m.). The top was almost cooked, but the rest wasn't. The liquid was VERY watery, and the cheese was curdled. We skimmed the top layer off, but I tossed the rest of it.

Oven temperature is not an issue, I know that. I'm wondering if the long soak in the water did something to change the chemistry of the potato slices.

Any thoughts?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack
Test Kitchen Notes

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack

by Chowhound Editors | If you're unsure how to eat canned sardines, we have some intriguing ideas for you. Usually tinned...

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter
Food News

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter

by Jen Wheeler | I love learning about the genesis of odd food names (and words in general), so the recent revelation...

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter
Guides

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter

by Heather Reid | Sourdough is having a moment—many people are hunkering down at home and embarking on new projects...

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 
How To

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 

by David Watsky | Staying in is the new going out—at least for now—and we've some fun ideas for making the most of your...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.