After a subpar experience with their service, we went back, having been assured that it was merely one off night. It was only that, indeed.
Service was, well, perfect. Our server was very friendly and capable. The rhythm was good. Everything arrived with good timing.
The oysters were excellent. Fresh and beautiful, each one from tasty and mild Le Mallets to bigger Bluepoints, and other kinds whose names escape me. The other food is consistent and delicious.
We will be back to Oyster Boy. These guys are pros who truly care about delivering a totally satisfying oyster experience.