My wife and I will be celebrating our 9th anniversary next weekend, and will be staying at the Willard Hotel near the White House. We're looking for some non-fancy, "normal" Italian within walking distance of our hotel (3 miles or less). We like places like Maggiano's and Macaroni Grill, but not so much Olive Garden. I’ve read good things about Ristorante Tosca and Obelisk, but after looking at their menus the food seems too weird for us. Price isn’t really an option, as long as the food is “normal” and the atmosphere is romantic and charming.