My wife and I are planning our first trip to NY in years. We have four nights and we'd like to have four interesting dinners. We're foodies from LA and our interest is in the food, not the "Scene." I've read some truly horrendous reviews of places - like Bouley Bakery - that have been well-reviewed in the national press. We're interested in trying a variety of places and we'd like to avoid any horror stories, so what are your recommendations?