Newport, RI foodie restaurant suggestion

My husband and I will be in Newport, RI in the beginning of June. We are self-proclaimed foodies and would love to hear suggestions for dinner/lunch. Although we care about atmosphere and service, our main objective is to find a place with fresh seafood, and delicious food. A lot of the reviews I've been reading have given mixed reviews:
Some say Tallulah is amazing and others are calling it "overpriced and leaves on a plate"
I'm also getting mixed reviews about Mooring. The only places that seem to have consistent good reviews are Anthony's in Middletown and Bouchard, but we need at least 3-4 more restaurants to visit during our stay. Thank you for the help!