Restaurants & Bars

Boston Area Pizza

Newbury Pizza: unappreciated and decent!


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 15

Newbury Pizza: unappreciated and decent!

tamerlanenj | Aug 10, 2006 06:51 PM

I am surprised that Newbury Pizza, a hole in the wall NY style slice joiny on Newbury betwen Fairfield and Exeter, doesn't get more attention.

I think they churn out a fair approximation of a new york slice, although they are inconsistent with crust thickness (tendency to be too thick sometiems towards the heel). The sauce has a nice, not too sweet flavor, and the slices are sufficiently olive-oily (but not greasy). Cheese is a straightforward Mozz, but at least isn't overloaded. The pizzaiolo/owner is a nice guy, too.

I think they have a tendency to undercook pies sometimes, so when I order mine I ask for them well-done (I like some char on the bottom, anyway).

No, it's not DiFara or anything like that, but I like it for what it is: a good standard NJ/NYC style slice joint. And it's one spot for a cheap lunch on overpriced, mediocre Newbury St. ($2.75 for a HUGE slice, $6.50 for half a pie, $11 for a whole), and I can't trek all the way out to Santarpio's every time I want pizza.

Considering how much pizza completely and horribly sucks in Boston, I would think this place would ply more trade and earn more attention.

Upper crust just opened across the street, which i'm sure will be hard on business. I like Upper Crust a great deal, but to me it is just a different experience than a standard slice-joint style slice.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound