Looking for a restaurant to celebrate my 31st birthday with my husband and about 10 of our other 30ish friends. Looking for something no further west than the queens border and no further east than East Northport. Ideally the place would be not too crowded but still fun, near water, won't rush us out, not too expensive (entrees in the $10-20 range), have a great selection of girlie drinks (flavored martinis or margaritas etc) and have decent (though not necessarily gourmet) food. A little bit of dancing would be fun (but preferably not a young hip hop scene). Ability to take reservations would also be a big plus.
What suggestions do you have? Would Bongo Bay in Port Washington work? Someone also mentioned a place in Glen Cove/Sea Cliff that sounded like a fun bar/restaurant but I didn't catch the name.... Also, I know I said no further East than E. Npt but would anything on Fire Island meet my criteria?