I posted the other day about dinner at Le Cirque. Not too many responses (thanks to those who did, though), but I have since chosen a few other places to round out our short stay.
Our first night we are going to try The Bar Room at The Modern.
Second night (after matinee performance) either Trattoria Trecolori or Esca. Sister isn't big on fish, but I thought TT was kind of boring. Maybe someone has another recommendtion that's close to the theater district? There's three of us, and we don't want to spend too much -- looking for kind of medium scale, since we're blowing our wad on the third night.
Third night, Le Cirque or Eleven Madison Park. I've made reservations at both places. Both are prix fixe menus, and EMP is farther away from where we're staying (by Time's Square), but it doesn't look like it's THAT much farther.