Restaurants & Bars

Outer Boroughs

Monkeytown last night


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars

Monkeytown last night

satsuma76 | Jan 28, 2008 06:42 AM

I had a really, really nice meal at Monkeytown in Williamsburg last night, so I thought I'd share....I've been going to Monkeytown for a while now, but not very often--every few months or so I'll try to grab a meal there, because the menu seems to change pretty dramatically on a regular basis, and the food is always interesting and creative (though I've definitely had some clunker dishes there in the past; an absolutely rancorous lasagna comes to mind, one that tasted like bad commune cooking). Last night, sure enough, the menu was completely unfamiliar to me--they seem to have abandoned the boutique-bistro-style menu (just a handful of dishes, like five appetizers and four mains) they've had in the past. Now it's a kind of staggeringly large menu, especially given the somewhat unusual ingredients that find their way into only one or two dishes (truffled sauerkraut? smoked grapes?). The menu--and the cocktail list, for that matter--exhibits the kind of culinary creativity that, for me, teeters between enticingly original and pretentiously perplexing. For every dish that I found myself curious and excited about--mmm, seared venison with celery root puree and cherry cabbage--there was a dish that just seemed like a weird and ostentatious combination of flavors--whaaaa, sea scallops with curried cauliflower, candied bacon and jalapeno caramel. Well, actually, it wasn't a 50-50 split between enticement and perplexity--most of the dishes sounded great. But there is, for sure, a haute cuisine-ish showiness to the menu that can be, at times, off-putting, at least to me.

All that said, the food I had was WONDERFUL. I asked for recommendations, and my server suggested I started with an item I NEVER would have ordered on my own--a "pastrami crab cake", which was served with the aforementioned truffled sauerkraut and a mysterious "hot pink mayo". This dish was fantastic, and fantastically fun. It ended up being a kind of wonderful take on the flavors of a Reuben: the "cake" was a pretty delicious homemade crab cake flecked with little tiny pieces of pastrami; the kraut was a nice homemade-tasting kraut with slices of some black mushroom (definitely not black truffle, given the size of the pieces, but certainly tasty), and the "hot pink mayo" turned out to be a wonderful tangy and spicy thousand-island/russian dressing kind of sauce. Like I said--a weird combo of Reuben flavors, + really nice crab. And it was wonderful, creative and fun and tasty and not too big--pretty much everything I like an appetizer to be.

For entree, I had a duck dish--roasted duck breast with a "leg confit and sweet potato hash" and a "cherry soy reduction". The breast itself, with the cherry soy was really nice: the breast was perfectly cooked, and a nice cut of meat, tender and with just a little bit of tasty duck fat. The sauce--ahem, excuse me, the reduction--was a tad too sweet for me, and I didn't really taste the soy-ness, but like I said, it was a really nice dish. The real star of the meal, however, was the side of confit-sweet potato hash, which was absolutely inspired and delicious. Tiny little cubes of sweet potato mixed with shredded crispy pieces of confit and a few whole chunks of sauteed garlic. It was absolutely divine, and--despite the expected heaviness of the confit--tasted remarkably fresh, light, and subtle. The flavors and textures were really perfectly put together--the soft creaminess of the sweet potato, the crispiness and meatiness of the confit, the crunchiness and tang of the garlic. A GREAT, GREAT dish. And the whole plate was great together; the breast, the hash, the sauce, all combined in a superlative way.

I didn't have dessert, and I didn't have a cocktail (their cocktail list, tho, is particularly crazy, and well worth checking out, if only for novelty value: ), although I was given a complimentary taste of the "beet-dill infused vodka" after I asked about it. (In addition to the cocktail menu, they have a small section on the menu proper titled "Eat Liquor", four drinks that my server said were conceived of as kind of savory liquors. The verdict: the vodka was actually rather awesome, but--disclaimer--I'm a sucker for borscht.)

To sum up: a really satisfying meal. My earlier grumblings about pretentiousness aside, I do enjoy the unusualness of the Monkeytown menu--however silly I may find some of the dishes, I really like the uniqueness of this restaurant, which is why, I suppose, I always go back. Oh, something else that looked interesting on the menu: something called the "Futurist Cookbook", which listed, simply, "1 course", "2 courses", "3 courses", and a "5 course tasting menu". I asked about this enigmatic little item, and apparently, on nights when the head chef is there (I was told he's there Tues-Sat, so, sadly, I was disqualified, leaving me to my hash-y fun), he'll make you whatever he's feeling like that night, unannounced mystery dishes. Which is kind of a cool thing to have on a menu; I thought that was a rather neat touch. All in all, my meal left me excited about Monkeytown again--like I said, I've had bad experiences there in the past, but it seems like they've really hit their stride.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound