I finally tried it this week (W 56th st location)
Crack Pie--very sweet and buttery, like pecan pie without the pecans.
Cornflake-marshmallow, peanut butter, and compost cookies--all extremely buttery and very, very sweet.
These weren't awful, mind you, but not really what I expected. I don't see the addictiveness of the Crack Pie at all, and if the cookies weren't so buttery to the point of being greasy, they probably would be excellent.
Just wondering, thanks.