Usually I get my coffee from JB Peel in Red Hook, but decided to try this place because it's closer. The storefront looks really small, but inside is a really comfortable cafe with a great lunch menu. Didn't have time to eat, but the coffee is fine. (Sleepy Hollow Reserve is what I bought.) Planning to go back for lunch.
Millerton badly needs a place like this, so hope it turns out great and sticks around. Apparently they are a sister store the the coffeehouse on Irving Place.