+
Beer, Cider, & Sake

Midwest Stout Blind-Tasting Championship and random stout notes

TombstoneShadow | May 22, 201407:01 AM     18

Yesterday began the arduous task of finding / updating my go-to stout lineup. I'm going to start with brews that are most widely available throughout the year in order to establish some "baselines". Then we'll finish up with some brews for which I only have 1 or 2 bottles per year.

For this first qualifier there were 4 candidates, tasted blind:

Great Divide Yeti (regular Yeti)
North Coast Old Rasputin
Rogue Shakespeare Oatmeal Stout
Samuel Smith's Chocolate Stout

I should note that within a very wide latitude I've drank so much stout over the years that I use flavored and unflavored brews inter-changeably. You'll see that throughout this taste off.

Should also note that to my palate, more than any other beer type, the flavor of stout is very temperature-sensitive and should not be served too cold as the flavors can lock-up and be a bit harsh. For me, the ideal temp is probably around 60-ish.

Actual tasting notes follow:

Beer 1: Nice rich flavor. Mild coffee and dates....

Beer 2: Sweet, tasty. A bit thinly-textured....

Beer 3: Dry, bitter. Just an uninteresting, singular "dusty" flavor.

Beer 4: Big, a bit harsh.
After Round 1 my preferences were still TBD, so after awhile to warm in the glasses on to Round 2:

Beer 4: Very complex, semi-dry wbut with a mid-range bittersweet flavor spike. Well made.

Beer 3: Yuck

Beer 2: Undeniably delicious if a bit over-stated.

Beer 1: Very nice. More of a classic middle-of-the-road stout.Mostly coffee with a hint of date / cherry.

Final ratings: The only certain loser here is Beer 3. Beers 1, 2, and 4 are still in the race. Beer 1 was probably the most classic stout, great at both chilled and room temperature. Beer 4 is very big but did better as it warmed. Beer 2 is tasty, obviously a chocolate stout, and suffers a bit from a thinner texture than the others.

Revealing the Beers:

Beer 1 (current "winner"): Old Rasputin.
Beer 2: Samuel Smith's Chocolate Stout
Beer 3: Rogue Shakespeare
Beer 4: Yeti.

These results come as no surprise. For years Old Rasputin has been among my go-to stouts in several regions of the country. A masterpiece of classic stout both in the bottle and on tap, not too overly nuanced, just a great rich brew.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

You'll Have Zero Beef with These Delicious Veggie Burgers
Recipe Round-Ups

You'll Have Zero Beef with These Delicious Veggie Burgers

by Caitlin M. O'Shaughnessy | Interest in veggie burgers has been rising for a while now (along with the general surge in plant...

5 Guacamole Mistakes You’re Making
Guides

5 Guacamole Mistakes You’re Making

by Dan Koday | Guac seems simple, but there are many ways it can go wrong—hence, these tips on how to make the best...

Upgrade Your Taco Tuesday with These Fresh Fruit Salsas
Recipe Round-Ups

Upgrade Your Taco Tuesday with These Fresh Fruit Salsas

by Jen Wheeler | Looking for a way to liven up your Taco Tuesday—or any summer dinner? Want something more than a sauce...

The Crispiest Fish Tacos Depend on a Surprising Secret Ingredient You'll Never Guess
Food News

The Crispiest Fish Tacos Depend on a Surprising Secret Ingredient You'll Never Guess

by Amy Schulman | Esteban Castillo was raised in Santa Ana, California, surrounded by palm trees and a population that...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.