I grew up on Oahu, but have lived in Seattle for the past six years (sadly). I'm going home for the holidays, and taking a mini trip with my boyfriend, who's from Seattle, to Maui for his first time. I've only been to Maui a handful of times, and we usually stay with family -- Aunty does all the cooking. So besides Tasty Crust and Komoda's bakery, I haven't really had the chance to eat out in Maui.
We're going to be there for 3 days, right before New Year's... any suggestions? We're picky about fresh sushi / seafood, but other than that, we just really enjoy good food. We're staying in Kihei and Makawao... Help!