Went to the new Caneel Bay Caribbean Grill, and had a fantastic dinner. We are not big on "jerk", but they have lots more than that, all very good. We had curried beef stew, a jerk pasta dish that was delicious (very spicy), mac and cheese (just OK), and sweet potato fries. The basket of hush puppies they bring instead of bread is worth the trip itself. Also pretty reasonable in the context of the general cost of dinner anywhere on the Island.
Also had great seafood takeout from Off the Hook, fantastic granola from Fat Cat's, and of course Mustache Bill's for breakfast and amazing fried clams.