New! Chowhound Cities: Satisfy your curiosity and your palate. Explore Cities
Discover the unexpected in Manhattan. Explore All of New York City
Restaurants & Bars 3

One if By Land..... Most Over-rated?

mortonhound | May 21, 2008 08:58 PM

I noticed today that One if By Land was listed as the most over-rated restaurant in Manhattan on -- actually, it was off of some other survey they linked to, but you get the idea....

I was really interested because as it turned out, I was having dinner their tonight -- someone I was meeting made reservations there.

So, anyway, here's my take: if you're expecting a really romantic (and I'm a guy, so you now I mean it :) ) place with what I think was very good service, One if by Land is a great place.... the ambience is just wonderful.

Food-wise, though, it was.... dull. Not bad in any way -- everything was "workmanlike"... service a tad bit slow, but I don't think you'd notice if you went there on a special occasion or a date.

But while it was decent, there was just no pizzazz to the food -- kind of like they "tried".... but nothing really sparked. I asked the person I was dining with about it and she said pretty much the same thing... would we go back? Probably not.... unless we wanted to go there for the room itself.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound