I'm having trouble coming up with a suggestion.
My cousin's husband's 50th birthday. Party of 9, including a finicky 10 year old and a less finicky 6 year old.
UWS would be easiest.
Several of the adults are kosher(ish) so a fish place would be a good solution. We did think of Mermaid Inn, but for parties of 8 or larger, they require a prix fixe, which wouldn't really work for the kids.
Neptune Room was ruled too expensive.
Any suggestions? Thanks!