General Discussion

Ice Cream

Ice Cream Taste Test Report


General Discussion 25

Ice Cream Taste Test Report

Cloudy | Sep 3, 2001 08:16 PM

The results are in. I organized a blind taste test of four respected vanilla ice creams using my boyfriend, the vanilla fan, as judge. The clear winner: HAAGEN DAZS! It won handily, based on both taste and texture. Second was a tie between Ben & Jerry's and Ronnybrook Farm, and fourth place went to Ciao Bella. Now in defense of Ciao Bella, I must admit that the pint I bought in their outlet turned out to have been partly melted & refrozen, ruining the texture. But the judge insisted that, regardless of the texture, the taste wasn't as intense as the others. I was very impressed with Ciao Bella's vanilla the one time I had it, and it should also be noted that it is a gelato rather than a high-butterfat premium ice cream and thus maybe shouldn't even be compared with the others. I guess I'll have to repeat the test sometime; any suggestions on other worthy ice creams (available in the NYC area) that should be included?

I'll report the results when he tests chocolate ice creams on me.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound