Hi Chowhounders - I'm seeing a 7pm show on Sunday and want to get a great meal beforehand. Theatre is at 49th and Broadway, so near there is ideal. I've found a lot of great-looking places, but we'd have to eat at 4:30 or 5pm at the latest, and most places don't open until 5:30.
The options that could work are Toloache and Marsielle.
Any other ideas?