Gramercy is booked my 1st choice, Been to Union Square. Taking the train up for the day to go to a matinee on the Saturday the 28th. Won't be very dressed up, more smart casual and don't want to brake the bank on this meal. Went to Charlie Trotter's and pretty much broke the bank in October.
Looking for good food, service, reasonable prices on food and wine. Does anyone strongly object or prefer one of these over the others.