Hi chowhounders! So my bf and I will be coming up for a weekend in May to celebrate my birthday. I'm really excited since I haven't been back to Montreal since this past fall. I have two dinners and after scouring the boards have chosen Garde Manger, Au Cinquieme Peche, Le Bleu Raisin, and DNA...only problem, that's 4:-) I'd like my birthday dinner to be in an intimate and lively atmosphere and the other dinner to be more romantic but I'm open. Garde Manger seems to be a good fit for the bday dinner. So I would love to hear which two restaurants you would choose and would greatly appreciate any feedback on these restaurants regarding food, price range (couldn't find a website for Garde Manger), atmosphere, etc...TIA!
Au Cinquieme Peche
4475 St-Denis, Montreal, QC H2J 2K8, CA