Restaurants & Bars

Outer Boroughs

Three fun stops on Atlantic Ave, and a crab question


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 3

Three fun stops on Atlantic Ave, and a crab question

Paul Lukas | Sep 1, 2003 04:37 PM

The galpal and I slept late on Labor Day and were planning to head over to Tom's Luncheonette in Prospect Hts around 1pm, but we stupidly forgot all about the parade. A series of police barricades shunted us over to Atlantic Ave., at which point we decided to forget about Tom's and cruise down thru Bed-Stuy and East New York instead. This turned out to be a great decision.

First stop was at the East Market Diner (corner of Atlantic and Georgia Aves). I'd noticed this joint while driving by about a jillion times but had never stopped there before. Turns out to be a classic diner with a friendly crowd, super-nice service, and absolutely *none* of that greasy smell that permeates so many diners. I had French toast (good) and the galpal had a turkey club (excellent) with fries (so-so) and two pickle spears (nice and garlicky). When we asked for iced tea, the waitress said, "Snapple or homemade?" -- nice. We got the latter, natch, and it was my-t-fine. Bottom line, including tax and tip: $16. All in all, this was solid, no-frills food, just like a diner should be, except it's so hard to find decent diners in NYC, so this one sorta feels like a treasure, especially given the very warm social vibe. Pretty classic diner aesthetics, too. Recommended.

Next was the always-wonderful Mrs. Maxwell's Bakery (Atlantic & Vermont), where, as their slogan goes, "It just isn't a party without Mrs. Maxwell's party cakes." Got a cupcake, a mini-cheesecake thingie, and a lemon meringue tart. Mmmmmmm.

Driving on a bit farther, we saw an odd sight on the sidewalk outside of Castillo's Seafood shop (Atlantic & Warwick). They had a big chicken-wire cage filled with crabs, and the crabs were climbing around on the walls and ceilings of the cage, literally hanging off of the sides and off of each other -- I've never seen crabs behave like this. Turns out they weren't blue crabs or calicos or Dungeness -- they were a rather drab blue-gray-ish variety I hadn't seen before, with big-ass claws. The proprietor said they were "Caribbean crabs." He was selling them for $8/lb., but we were already stuffed from our previous stops, so we didn't buy any. Anyone familiar with this particular crustacean?

Brooklyn is so damn cool!

-- Paul

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound