The hubs and I are headed to Lahaina Dec 29 - Jan 5. We love great food at all price points, but are interested in the best of what the area has to offer. We will have a car, and are happy to drive. So far, we are going to Feast at Lele for NYE (more for the experience than the food; I have moderate to low expectations about the food); I'm thinking Banyon Tree for the hubs' birthday, and maybe Mama's for dinner the day we're leaving (our flight isn't until 11:30 or so that evening - would 5:30 reservations be too early/late? Is that not a good idea?).
I'd appreciate any comments on the above, and would welcome any comments on places (at all price ranges) that we shouldn't miss.