+
Home Cooking

Eggplant parmesan fail - what am I doing wrong?

clairebbbear | Jun 10, 201306:07 AM     70

So I've made three batches of eggplant parmesan using three different methods of cooking the eggplant, and I count all three as fails. What I want is a method that cooks the eggplant so it's still firm and meaty - so that it could almost be mistaken for meat in texture - but not dry and leathery. I can't seem to get the texture right - it's either too dry or too soggy.

In all three methods I cut the eggplant into 1/2 inch slices, crumbed the eggplant slices and, after cooking them in various ways, layered and baked it for 30 minutes with the marinara sauce.

First batch I baked the eggplant instead of frying - I salted the eggplant for 30 minutes first, then crumbed them, then baked for 30 minutes turning halfway, then added the sauce/cheese etc and baked. The eggplant tasted nice but was too soggy.

Second batch I didn't salt the eggplant first as I was in a hurry. Breaded the slices then fried in a very small amount of oil - just sprayed the pan basically. The texture was closest to what I want but still a bit leathery, and the eggplant tasted bitter.

Third batch i salted first, crumbed then fried in a much larger amount of oil - about 1/2 inch deep in a wide skillet. I'm pretty sure the oil was hot enough. Cooked the slices until they were golden brown - about 1-2 minutes each side. Then layered and baked as usual. This one was a total disaster, the slices had basically disintegrated - way too sloppy.

I'm struggling to know what I'm doing wrong. The only thing i can think of with the last method - which is basically the standard method - was that I ran out of paper towels so that I didn't drain the fried slices of the oil before laying them, at least not as much as I'd like. Could this have made all the difference?

I read about another method, that involves salting/pressing the slices while pre-cooking them in an oven for 30 minutes, or a microwave for 3 minutes, then frying as per usual. I'm thinking of doing this plus the "minimum oil" flying method.

Any other ideas what I could try? Also, once I have the recipe sorted out I want to make a big batch so I can freeze and re-heat it (unbaked), so I need to take that into account.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

The Best Way to Cook Bacon Is Actually the Easiest (& Cleanest)
Chow with Me

The Best Way to Cook Bacon Is Actually the Easiest (& Cleanest)

by Hana Asbrink | Pixabay Welcome to Chow with...

This Essential Campfire Cooking Gear Make For Great Father's Day Gifts
Food News

This Essential Campfire Cooking Gear Make For Great Father's Day Gifts

by Jessica Gentile | Ahh, the great outdoors. You hiked the trails, pitched a tent, and inhaled the freshest air you've...

Slow Cooker Bourbon Ribs for Father's Day
Slow Cooker

Slow Cooker Bourbon Ribs for Father's Day

by Chris Rochelle | Father's Day dinner is deserving of a big bold showstopper of a dish, and this meaty, moist, fall...

14 Slow Cooker Recipes Perfect for Father’s Day
Recipe Round-Ups

14 Slow Cooker Recipes Perfect for Father’s Day

by Chowhound Editors | Wondering what to make for dad this Father's Day? Let's go against type for a moment. Just because...

Trending Discussions

1

Simple Syrup

Updated 8 hours ago 3 comments
2

Quality Informal Flatware for Oxymorons

Updated 11 hours ago 8 comments
4

Skimming Fat

Updated 2 hours ago 37 comments
5

Electric Skillet Recommendations

Updated 12 hours ago 8 comments

See what's new!

View latest discussions ›

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.