Home Cooking 2

doubling a cookie recipe, double baking soda too?

ediecooks | Jan 13, 201203:10 PM

I recently made the very basic, usually reliable 'vanishing oatmeal cookie' recipe from the Quaker box. I had a glut of eggs and butter left from holiday baking so while I had the mess out, I decided to double the recipe, including doubling the baking soda.

the cookies came out with a weird sort of metallic tang to them! I am 1000% sure I used soda, not powder, and did everything right. my sister has noticed a similar occurrence when she doubles a pumpkin bread recipe that is also usually reliable and basic.

any thoughts? are you not supposed to double the b. soda in a case like this? is there some chart of proportions?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›
Log In or Sign Up to comment

Recommended From CH