I need help for our upcoming 20th anniversary in July. We come up from Philly once or twice a year and absolutely love NYC. Our most memorable meals have been at Eleven Madison Park and Blue Hill (wow was that heaven!), and these are the types of places that my wife enjoys (she absolutely loved Blue Hill).
So, I'm asking for suggestions on a place that serves food at least of the quality of the two aforementioned places, in a lovely atmosphere, and for about the same price ($200-250 max including wine and tip). Hope this doesn't limit me too much. How about places like Tabla, Craft, Town, the new Blue Hill at Stone Barns, etc.? Wife loves places that are very stylish and hip, without being trendy or over the top. Thanks hounds, you have helped out in the past, I'm sure you'll help this time!