Restaurants & Bars


Columbia (MO) Update


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars

Columbia (MO) Update

SmallCap | Apr 29, 2008 03:46 PM

(I am posting this thread separately rather than under the post seeking "kid-friendly" options in the same city, as I know one of the places I'm reviewing would NOT qualify & I am not sure on the other!)

Following the demise of my local favorite (Village Wine & Cheese) & coupled with my desire to break out of our typical Addison’s/Sophia's rut, we tried two new spots in Columbia last week: Hemingway's (off of Nifong) + Mackenzie's (north of I-70 off of Rangeline).

Hemingway's was nice in the tradition (& price range) of Sophia's -- a fairly eclectic menu, a decent selection of high-prized appetizers, a lively patio, etc. (Their "20 Bottles Under $20" wine list was actually what drew us there, but that's a whole other topic.) Probably the best part of the meal, & the reason I would return versus places in a similar vein, were their crepes. They are made in the very thin & un-overstuffed tradition I prefer, & the one we chose with came unadorned with any sauce held up better than the one we chose which came with a sauce too heavy for the delicate crepe itself. That is probably the one Hemingway’s tendency that I disliked -- sauces too heavy & too overpowering for the food, although this is problem I seem to encounter quite frequently. Anyway, it is still a nicely upscale (& very romantic, at least in the main dining room) spot, & their little wine-shop with the walk-in humidor is a nice addition to the business. (I'll admit that the young serving/hostessing staff does have a ways yet to go.) My guess is Hemingway's will do well in Columbia over the long-term.

For something completely different, Mackenzie's was a real delight. They cook their steaks & seafood (& other proteins too, I assume) over an open-flame wood-fired grill; as we learned, the chimney design of the grill is actually the invention of the proprietor who received his training at a place called CC Broilers (which may mean something to any of you who are locals...?). Anyway, the quality of the meat + seafood was excellent, arrived in perfectly-sized portions, & was served unadorned except for the beautiful woodsmoke flavor -- but when the quality of the cut & preparation is that strong, the food can (& should) stand on its own. Sides were standard (some upcharges) & the salads (included in the price of entree, an added bonus) were considerably better than your typical side salad. As I posted on the "Mid Mo Dining Guide" site, Mackenzie's really had the atmosphere & feel (staff, patrons, prices, patio, etc.) of a "neighborhood"-type restaurant but with the menu selection, wine list, & food quality of a much nicer -- & pricier -- place. They don't try to do too much, & I think that's an excellent strategy. My only complaints would be the appetizers (too much breading & some subpar quality -- I think this is the only area where they fall into the trap of overreaching) & the itsy-bitsy-teeny-weeny wine glasses which are vastly inadequate for the relatively optimistic wine list. I get the sense that many of their patrons are "regulars," including family of the owner, so I wouldn't describe the atmosphere as romantic... more "comfortable"... yet still delightful.

(Oh, & one quick comment -- had decent Thai food at a spot called "The Blue Moon," also off of Nifong, which offered decent curries but seemed to be such a greasy, dive-y type place with staff of the same ilk that I am not sure I could return! There must be better Thai options in the city, or at least Thai food that doesn't come with sticky chairs & dirty tables!)


Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound