Home Cooking

Ice Cream

Caramel Peach Ice Cream report--a mixed result


Home Cooking 12

Caramel Peach Ice Cream report--a mixed result

LindaMc | Sep 2, 2005 10:09 AM

Having heard of, but not tasted, this flavor, I was keen to try it. Following the advice of (I think) curiousbaker from a previous post, I made a caramel sauce first, using a recipe from a pastry course I took last year at the CIA. I can post the formula if anyone is interested. I tried to make the caramel on the bitter side, since I like that flavor. I also added some salt.

I then made a Philadelphia-style peach ice cream, using about 3 c peaches, 2 c cream, 1 c whole milk, 1 egg, 1/2 c sugar, a spoonful of vanilla and a drop of almond extract. I warmed the peaches first with a bit of sugar, then added the juice and about half of the peaches to the cream mixture.

After chilling, I ran the cream mix through my machine for a little over 20 minutes, then mixed in the rest of the peaches and the caramel by hand.

Results: This methodology worked--caramel sauce is a great addition. But the result was a bit sweet for me, without a strong note of peach. And my efforts to make the caramel less cloying did not seem to help much. My husband, who has a fierce sweet tooth, loved it.

I'm not sure what, if anything, I can do to tone down the sweetness. The problem might have been that peaches in our area (Washington DC) are not as flavorful as they were a few weeks ago--I was tasting all the way through the process and the flavor seemed a bit muted. I tried to balance with the almond extract, but I am not a huge fan of this and don't like it as an identifiable flavor in the final product. Maybe I should have added some lemon juice, but I was afraid the lemon would overwhelm the peaches.

I plan to try this approach again with some nice tart apples soon--I think that combination might work better. In the meantime, if ice cream obssessed hounds have any thoughts, I'd welcome them.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound