+
Restaurants & Bars

Butter Pie (Butter Love Bakeshop) at the Underground Market

david kaplan | Apr 23, 201102:54 PM     8

This was going to be a lukewarm post about the daytime underground market today (which goes until 4 before reopening at 6 with a nighttime cast) until I tried the butter pie from Butter Love Bakeshop, which I bought and started eating just now at home. Butter pie is pecan pie minus pecans with a denser filling, somewhere between the pecan pie goo and toffee. The filling is too sweet on its own, and the crust is (purposely?) overcooked so it is almost burnt on its own, but together the near-bitter crust and too-sweet filling balance perfectly. Really perfectly. Going to their website -- they're online only -- I saw they linked to a NYTimes article about pie that featured them and their butter pie recipe (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/17/din...). I remember reading that article months ago but didn't make the connection to today's delicious butter pie until I got home and tried the pie.

The other highlight was the OaktownJerk beef jerky: thick slabs of tender jerky, with several flavor options. I liked all of the spicier flavors: thai basil; star anise and habanero; and chili lime chipotle.

Someone served chai; that was good, too.

I didn't care for the marshmallow snacks, which were more brown rice than marshmallow and tasted too much like health-food rice krispy squares. One vendor offered several savory "cupcakes"; I tried the macaroni and cheese crumble, which was overcooked, almost crunchy, and skimped on the promised sausage and chili.

I went around opening time, at 11. Just about everyone was set up on time, and it was uncrowded and middle-aged, which is what I hoped; I was not looking for a hipster party scene like it apparently becomes in the evening portion.

My biggest disappointment was that Baia pasta was not there; they're only coming tonight, and I was hoping to take home some of their dried pasta. I assumed they'd be there during the day when the vendors are mostly take-away, but I now see their website says they'll only be there tonight.

-----
Butter Love
San Francisco, CA, San Francisco, CA

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

12 Irish Foods to Celebrate St. Patrick's Day That Aren’t Corned Beef and Cabbage
Recipe Round-Ups

12 Irish Foods to Celebrate St. Patrick's Day That Aren’t Corned Beef and Cabbage

by Megan Meadows | If you're not a fan of corned beef, there are still plenty of delicious ways to celebrate St. Patrick...

15 St. Patrick's Day Recipes Perfect to Pair with Beer
Recipe Round-Ups

15 St. Patrick's Day Recipes Perfect to Pair with Beer

by Caitlin M. O'Shaughnessy | If you're planning to down a few pints of the black stuff this St. Patricks Day, you'd be wise to...

7 Things to Do with Leftover Corned Beef
Recipe Round-Ups

7 Things to Do with Leftover Corned Beef

by Caitlin McGrath | One of the best things about the corned beef you've cooked for St. Patrick's Day is turning the leftover...

A One-Pot Skillet Shepherd’s Pie Built out of Pantry Staples
Food News

A One-Pot Skillet Shepherd’s Pie Built out of Pantry Staples

by Anna Gass | Although it may be difficult to muster up feelings of celebration on this year’s St. Patrick’s Day...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.