In the past month I have eaten more than my fair share of restaurant desserts. As promised I am going to try and give a report.
Best desserts: Oliveto, Delfina and Bar Tartine
2nd best: Ame, Lalime's and Rubicon
Worst: Campton Place and Salt House
Oliveto's desserts were clean, simple and perfect. We ordered the whole menu. They got points for seasonality & innovation, as well as a dessert I had much disdain for initially but blew me away: a "Raisin Tart" with a tender, delicate, buttery crust. My favorite was a mandarin orange frozen parfait and an impressive coco nib pannacotta-- silky smooth, not too much gelatin, redolent of chocolate without the heavyness of actual chocolate.
At Delfina we had the carnaroli pudding with cherry compote, buttermilk pannacotta and pistachio gelato. The carnaroli was my favorite but i like the new plating on the pannacotta-- there was a tangerine miroir/gelee on top instead of the usual caramel. I don't like my pistachios toasted, but the gelato was great otherwise: good strong flavour.
Bar Tartine has come a long way. Desserts tasted: Rose geranium pannacotta with rhubarb consomme and stewed rhubarb, and Chocolate mousse cake with red beet ice cream, sesame tuile, candied kumquats & beets.
The first one was surprisingly nice, if a bit sweet. The rose geranium flavour was well balanced, although the whole dessert was fairly soft. Coconut chunks were floating in the soup that didn't make sense, but besides that all was well executed.
Beet ice cream was creamy and not "dirty" tasting the way beets tend to taste as a concentrated flavor. Mousse was light in texture, tuile flavor didn't make much sense on the plate but it was delicious, kuquats were great for acid and bitterness against a mostly sweet dessert, but neither of us appreciated the actual beets on the plate.
Ame and Rubicon get points for trying hard. For giving it a go at seasonality (I looked at the Americano dessert menu and 3 out of 4 desserts were chocolate.) and pretty plating styles. Although Ame played it so safe it felt boring and Rubicon took some poetic license I didn't appreciate.
Ame: Chocolate Mousse Crunch with chocolate sorbet and sour cherry red wine compote, Rhubarb Pie with strawberry ice cream, and strawberry salad, Meyer Lemon Beignet with mango Lassi and Black Cardamon honey.
The choc. dessert was seamlessly executed and pretty to look at but it lacked soul or depth. To much sameness. The crunch at the bottom of the mousse-cake had peanuts in it which didn't make sense in the overall flavor profile and the sorbet only tasted of cocoa.
The strawberry dessert was confused. The crust on the pie was possibly made of just cream it was so tender, but the pie itself had little to no sugar which didn't work with the corresponding garnishes. A strawberry ice cream seemed overly sweet in comparison and tasted so strongly of strawberry it made me and my companion suspicious. Are they using fruit puree? What let us know they were was the "strawberry salad"was a few haphazardly sliced strawberries with coulis poured over the top, but, the strawberries themselves had no flavor. (or the flavor of commercial strawberries in March.)
The beignets were also confusing. they were indeed yeated doughnuts, fried to perfection, but they tasted nothing of Meyer Lemon. There were three components: "beignets," lassi and a pot of marmalade. The sauce over the doughnuts was barely cardamon nor honey. A pretty plate, but not cohesive.
Rubicon's pastry chef is doing a good job, but could be doing a lot better. The chef's food is more refined than hers and it shows in comparison. Desserts ordered: Bittersweet chocolate pecan crepes with oven roasted pear and Szechuan Pepper Sabayon, Spiced Apple Beignets with dried Moyer Plums and salted caramel ice cream, and Pistachio Rose petal Meringue with honeycomb, dates and yogurt sorbet.
the chocolate dessert should be named something else. Three, what looked to be fried but are actually baked tiny square puffs are served in a bowl with sabayon in the middle and the plum-pear stuff going on underneath, the sabayon could be a dessert all on it's own it's so fantastic. Subtle, light, gorgeous deliciousness! Fantastic use of/for a strong spice. Two puffs are filled with very bittersweet chocolate (cake batter?) and one is filled with pecan pie filling without the nuts. the bowl could use to have more balance-- maybe another pecan pie puff? maybe actual crepes if that's what the menu says? The baked puffs are almost impossible to cut with a fork, and although you could just pick one up and pop it in your mouth, it would deliver too powerful a punch t be able to taste anything else.
The beignets are not that. They are overcooked, dry, cake doughnut middles, small and covered with too much sugar. besides the ok ice cream, this dessert is not good. And because salted caramel ice cream is on so many dessert menus, it shouldn't show up unless it's very very good. (Like the version at BiRite creamery.)
The pistachio-rose petal dessert is very pretty, but quite small in relation to the amount and size of the other desserts, like a quarter of the size. I liked the flavors although my companion was put off by how cold it was. I imagine the sorbet is pre-scooped and frozen so that it will stand up to a torch on the meringue exterior. The rose water flavor was strong and could do to be pulled back on, but this was the best dessert overall.
At Campton Place we ordered every sngle dessert so I can safely say that they were all awful. The dessert of carrot ravioli and avocado mousse was fine, if you like those flavors. Me not being one to be impressed with smoke an mirrors I found the flavor man behind the curtain to be missing. This is a European trained pastry chef so the execution is spot-on, but much of the components were so bitter or strongly flavored we could not eat more than a few polite bites. If you are looking for very "strange" flavor combinations and that's all you care about, these desserts are for you. But too many of them tasted only of a particular alcohol used or the overall flavor compositions were too confusing to get a straight read on any of them. So unsatisfying it made me sad.
Salt House was worse than Campton Place because the desserts had no flavor at all. We also ordered the entire dessert menu so it's not that we didn't have "the good one." A rhubard gratin was raw rhubarb set into pastry cream with a burnt custard crust (not bruleed with sugar or anything), what looked to be overcooked granola on top and a scoop of flavorless (rhubarb?) sorbet. There was a chocolate mousse thing which was dense and weird. A lemon pudding cake which was dry (isn't the point of the pudding cake to be moist?) with scattered huckleberries on the plate, a "marshmallow" that was no more than a stale piece of meringue, a bitter maple-walnut tart with tough crust, a giant scoop of ok banana ice cream, although too sweet, on top, a very odd pineapple-coconut triangle parfait on top of dry cake-- the pineapple was not ripe, the plating was something out of the midwest and the cake was practically inedible. Considering that the pastry chef was recently featured in The SF Chronicle I though these desserts were going to wow me with at least flavor. But from the childish plating style to the execution to the flavor, this was the worst experience of them all.
What I learned is that SF likes to follow trends. Chocolate mousse, doughnuts and attempts at odd pairings appear to be all the rage. Seasonality still has a long way to travel, even in our organic-local-farmers' market driven city.
Restaurants for desserts I'd still like to try: Boulevard, Ritz Carleton Dining Room, Jojo, and Masa's (just to see who they get next.)
Thanks for the suggestions initially!