+
General Discussion

Awful tasting real maple syrup - what the heck?

FitMom4Life | Aug 17, 201507:30 PM     20

I have had real maple syrup, years ago, I'm certain. And I am pretty sure I thought it was yummy. But we always just use the imitation stuff as we don't use it that much, and lately not at all. My BF would rather go to WaffleHouse for his waffles and that is fine with me. (And I try to not even eat pancakes or waffles anymore so the syrup just doesn't much matter to me.)

Anyway...so my BF just got a huge jug of the real thing from a friend of his that was just up north for a visit. Since he doesn't use it at home really at all, he gave it to me. And since I don't really use it either, I figured I would bake something with it. So I made a maple cake, using 2 cups of the stuff. When I was pouring the batter into the pans, it just didn't smell "mapley", so I tried it, and there was no maple flavor at all. I actually wound up baking the cake, and then throwing it out as I was making it for work and just thought it was a sub-par flavor.

So I got curious, and I sniffed the syrup, and it smelled, well, wrong somehow. Not "bad", as in spoiled, but not like maple syrup. Nothing like maple syrup. Almost had a chemically smell. So I tried it, from a spoon. It tasted no better than it smelled, and honestly I cannot imagine anyone actually LIKING that taste. My BF tried it and had the same reaction. So I google the stuff, and read that Trader Joes has really good maple syrup, so I went there and bought some (for $13!). I figured this had to be good, so I would compare it to the other. Well, it was just a hair less objectionable. I mean, only a little "less bad". What the hell? I don't understand. Neither jug is expired, both are over a year away from the "best by" date.

This is really perplexing, so I went to Fresh Market today, and bought a bottle of their maple syrup, (brand was Highland Sugarworks), opened it and tried it, and it was pretty good. Then I bought a bottle of the Fresh Market brand, and it was more like the other stuff, quite different from the Highland stuff.

So I am really confused here. I figured that all "real" maple syrup would taste quite yummy, especially the Trader Joe stuff. But it isn't, not at all.

Anyone else have this experience? Could it be that I have lost my taste for the stuff by only using the imitation syrup?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

Thanksgiving Budgeting (& Cooking) Tips from a Restaurant Pro
Guides

Thanksgiving Budgeting (& Cooking) Tips from a Restaurant Pro

by David Watsky | Cooking a big meal for a big group on Thanksgiving—or anytime–is an exercise in organization, planning...

Keeping It Real: How Far Should You Go to Accommodate Thanksgiving Guests?
Entertaining

Keeping It Real: How Far Should You Go to Accommodate Thanksgiving Guests?

by Remy Patrizio | If you're hosting Thanksgiving dinner, you want to welcome and accommodate your guests—but just how...

Christmas Crack: The Easiest and Most Addictive Holiday Gift
How To

Christmas Crack: The Easiest and Most Addictive Holiday Gift

by Mijon Zulu | Want some crack? I mean, crackle? People who have had it love it and it takes less than an hour to...

Melissa Clark's Maple Syrup Pecan Pie Is a Star
My Go-To

Melissa Clark's Maple Syrup Pecan Pie Is a Star

by Meredith Arthur, Blake Smith, and Jen Wheeler | Pecan pie is right up there with pumpkin pie when it comes to iconic holiday desserts, but it has...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.