I stopped by last Friday after work. The space is still pretty spartan, but is more than filled with Anthony's outsized personality. I picked up a dozen (bumped to a baker's dozen, a bit under $10) cookies, half 'cookies & cream' and half toffee chip. I don't have much of a sweet tooth (these were ostensibly for my SO), but I couldn't stop eating these. Both flavors were remarkably complex, and not at all cloying or heavy-handed with the butter.
I spotted Giusto's flour bags in back, but didn't think to ask about the organic-ness of the other ingredients. Honestly, with cookies these good I'm not entirely concerned.
Located between 25th and 26th on Valencia; not a lot of foot traffic, and easy to miss. I hope they do well.
1417 Valencia Street, San Francisco, CA