Restaurants & Bars

Chicago Area

Amateur Night (long)


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 8

Amateur Night (long)

chicgail | Feb 15, 2008 04:55 AM

So last night Mr. CG and I went out to celebrate Valentine's Day. Now I know that, next to NYE, V-D is probably the worst of all possible nights to go out.

And to make matters worse, Mr. CG didn't get around to making reservations until 3:30 pm on the day-of. He found something at Green Dolphin Street at 7:30 and since we live in the neighborhood and had never tried it, it seemed like a good idea.

GDS greeted us, had our reservation and a long-stemmed red rose for me. So far so good. We got escorted to our table and discovered, not surprisingly, that they had a "special" menu for V-D.

We were served slightly stale cold rolls with wrapped pats of butter a-la Mitchells for breakfast.

The menu included a spinach salad with fruit or a spinach salad Cesar (that's what it said); a sorbet intermezzo; entree choices were salmon or fillet or a veggie plate.

They took our drink orders (no onions for Mr. CG's gibson so he had a martini) and a rather sweet cosmo for me and immediately took our dinner orders. Ok, not much to read; not much to choose from. We both chose the spinach Cesar and the filet.

Salads came immediately. Not spinach at all, but, (appropriately) romaine -- with olives(?). A nice touch was a toast point topped with a fresh anchovy instead of croutons.

Bus persons very eager to pull the plates away when we paused and then, before we had finished the salads, delivered two asian-style spoons filled with huge scoops of sweet strawberry sorbet. No way to taste the "intermezzo" without making a mess, so I requested spoons.

Quickly on the heels of the sorbet -- they were eager to turn those tables -- came the entree and then the waiter wanting to know if we wanted wine. Not for me, a little too late.The filet was cooked as ordered and topped with dry blue cheese. Asparagus spears and a tomato bruchetta also on the plate.

Dessert plates followed with a dry chocolate cake, two de rigeur chocolate-covered strawberries, an ice cream profiterole and a waver filled with sponge cake topped with sliced strawberries, mango and starfruit.

Now here's what I want to know.

1) Who else had a restaurant V-D experience worth talking about? Either a great one or a total disappointment.

2) Was our experience at Green Dolphin Street a typical, albeit exaggerated example of what to expect there or should we try it again on a quieter night?

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound