Restaurants & Bars

Boston Area

2nd excellent time at Benatti (Inman Sq)


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 17

2nd excellent time at Benatti (Inman Sq)

newhound | Mar 15, 2008 04:27 AM

Four of us went last night to Benatti near Inman Square, the second time we've been. I have to say, this place is an absolute gem. If you like interesting and extremely well-prepared upper-end Italian, you must go if you haven't been. We were blown away.

The room was about half full at 8 pm, and we started with a bottle of represso Valpolicelli, really solid and rich. For apps we split the scallops in orange juice reduction, simple grilled vegetables with olive oil (asparagus, eggplant, tomato, zuchini) and a simple mixed greens with balsamic and walnuts. The reduction sauce on those scallops-- oh! Fennel, sauteed spinach, incredible.

Mains we all passed around included half portions of the risotto e funghi porcini and the gnocchi, both great-- the risotto was incredibly fragrant with white truffle oil and parmesan, and very rich. Portions here are small but very filling and satisfying. We had the tortellini a aceto balsamico, with its creamy balsamic and walnut sauce over fresh spinach and ricotta pasta-- really balanced and different, a little revelation. A simple fettucine bolognese was very nice, although alongside the lasagna we had on our first trip, Benatti's red-sauced pastas are less interesting than the other sauces.

Our fifth main was a special, a spectacular rack of lamb dish, with four good-sized chops in a Barolo reduction with a touch of fresh mint, panko and a nicely sharp mustard crust. Simply the best lamb dish I've had in years. Superb quality meat, so well cooked, and like everything at Benatti, really well-thought out complementary flavors in the sauce.

For dessert, we had the croccanti, an almond meringue semifreddo-- superb; the carmelized banana with cardamom creme anglais and a thick belgian chocolate mousse, and a cheese plate with a great funky Corsican goat as the best selection-- all were well handled and delicious; my only critical note is that the three cheeses offered were narrow in range-- less variety than I generally like in a cheese plate.

Service was easygoing and attentive, and we lingered over a second bottle of wine. Anna, the hostess, remembered our first visit, and both the chef and pastry chef came by to chat. This is a little place-- only ten tables or so, and intimate. I worry a bit about their fit for the neighborhood in the long term, but truly I think they deserve a shot. I don't think you'll be let down--

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound