1 of 26
Oat of this Swirled
Born of the nationwide desire to bring back Ben & Jerry's much-beloved yet discontinued Oatmeal Cookie Chunk, this flavor is pretty similar to its dearly departed cousin. It still has the chocolate chunks and the cookie swirls, but instead of cinnamon ice cream, Oat of this Swirled features a sweet cream brown sugar substrate and concentrates the cinnamon into the cookie swirls. Fans of Oatmeal Cookie Chunk will be nostalgically satisfied.