Malatesta, a West Village favorite year-round, is even more appealing these days—partly for its outdoor tables with views of the Hudson, but especially for its spaghetti alla chitarra. This near-universal hound pick is simple summer perfection: faultlessly cooked pasta with chopped tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil. “Absolutely their best pasta dish,” declares vvvindaloo.
This friendly, midpriced trattoria gets high marks across the board for rustic, authentic Italian. Salads are a highlight; try the Caprese, grilled portobello, or orange, arugula, and Parmesan. Also recommended: grilled calamari, veal meatballs in tomato sauce, spinach gnocchi in Gorgonzola sauce, rosemary-and-garlic-scented grilled lamb chops, and panna cotta for dessert. “I love Malatesta and find it more similar to dining in Italy than most Italian places here in the city,” sums up billyeats. “Its laid-back style, casual but attractive atmosphere, and fresh, simple dishes just hit the mark.”
A step down in price and atmosphere, yet equally satisfying on its own terms, is the Pepe Rosso minichain, allenbank reminds us. The Sullivan Street original—best of the Pepes, in his book—dishes up some of the city’s tastiest home-style pasta “at prices to make you do a double-take.” allen’s favorites include penne with spinach and ricotta ($6.95) and garlicky penne with tomato and basil ($5.95). “And where else,” he asks, “can you get a nice-sized plastic cup of easily drinkable wine (red or white) for $4.50?”
In other Italian news, SoHo’s Ravioli Store has closed its doors. But a sign in the window promises that its pastas—filled with beets, squash, spinach and artichoke, and wild mushroom and truffles, among other things—will still be made wholesale and sold in other stores. Check the website (not yet updated at press time) for further info.
For an old-school alternative a few blocks north, sing me a bar recommends the venerable Raffetto’s, which has been rolling out dependably good spinach-ricotta ravioli and other fresh pastas for more than a century.
Malatesta Trattoria [West Village]
649 Washington Street (at Christopher), Manhattan
Raffetto’s [Greenwich Village]
144 W. Houston Street (between MacDougal and Sullivan), Manhattan