In honor of Cinco de Mayo, learn how to make authentic Mexican mole casero. Just follow along with our senior video producer, Guillermo Riveros, on a recent visit to Casa Pública in Brooklyn, where executive chef Bob Truitt and chef de cuisine Gustavo Rodriguez shared their secrets.

Contrary to widespread popular belief, Cinco de Mayo is not equivalent to Mexico’s 4th of July; it commemorates the Mexican victory over the French army in 1862 at the Battle of Puebla. In America especially, the date has blossomed into a general celebration of Mexican culture, which often just means an excuse to eat lots of tacos washed down with copious margaritas. And maybe take shots of tequila or mezcal.

We’d never say no to tacos or drinks, but May 5 is a fitting occasion to dabble in more authentic Mexican food, from Puebla in particular, and mole is the perfect party dish. It does take time to prepare (there were no shortcuts in pre-Hispanic cooking, after all), but it’s definitely worth it. As another clue to its special-occasion status, note the fact that it includes cacao, which the Aztecs used as currency. Unlike, say, edible 24-karat gold leaf, chocolate brings a ton of flavor to the dish.

authentic Mexican mole recipe

Chowhound

Making Mole

Take a closer look at some of the essential ingredients in mole, and then put them all together in the recipe below.

Chocolate

These days, chocolate may not be quite as precious as actual paper money, but it’s still an essential ingredient in this mole—seek out discs of Mexican chocolate, which is made from cacao nibs coarsely ground with sugar, cinnamon, and almonds. Abuelita is a brand commonly found in grocery stores, as is Ibarra (they both happen to come in hexagonal, yellow cardboard boxes, so are fairly easy to spot on the shelf).

Nestle Abuelita Mexican Chocolate Tablets, $3.39 on Amazon

Great for mole, or a cup of Mexican hot chocolate.
Buy Now

Chiles

One of the other key components of the mole sauce is the chile powder, which is best made at home from a mix of dried chiles that you stem, de-seed, and toast until brittle, then grind to a fine powder. While it adds a bit more time to the recipe, it’s not difficult to do, and the payoff is immense. In a pinch, you can use store-bought chile powder, but make sure it’s super fresh, and a blend that includes a variety of peppers for more nuanced depth of flavor. (To guide you, this recipe calls for four different kinds of peppers: mulato chiles, ancho chiles, pasilla chiles, and dried chipotle chiles; see the Shopping List below for notes on what each one brings to the dish.)

If this already feels daunting, though, you can also try a Mexican mole spice blend like this one, which includes chocolate and other ingredients in addition to ancho and chipotle chiles:

Spice Jungle Dry Mexican Mole Spice Blend, $8.65 on Amazon

Sometimes you just want a shortcut.
Buy Now

Toasted Spices, Nuts, and Seeds

Mingling with the already-layered flavors of chiles and chocolate, you have a delicious mix of spices in your mole sauce, including cinnamon, cloves, allspice, and oregano—which are all toasted to bring out their best. Toasted almonds are added as well, along with toasted sesame seeds. Sensing a theme?

Charred Vegetables

Yes, even the vegetables are charred to bring additional dimension to the long-simmered, complex sauce. Onions, plum or Roma tomatoes, and tart green tomatillos are easily blistered in a cast iron skillet, then go right into the blender along with the other mole base ingredients.

Instagram giveaway alert: Enter to win* a Vitamix blender by May 6!

Masa

Some cooks use toasted breadcrumbs to thicken their mole sauce, but this one uses a combo of masa and chicken stock. You can also use the masa to make homemade tortillas for wrapping around your filling of choice and smothering in mole sauce. (See the video up top for pointers on homemade tortillas too!)

Maseca Instant Corn Masa Flour, $2.88 at Walmart

A classic brand you can find in lots of places.
Buy Now

Chef-Grade Masa Flour, $14 at Masienda

This is the favorite brand at Casa Publica.
Buy Now

Lard (Manteca)

Rendered pork fat tastes good and it’s authentic, but if you can’t find any lard or just don’t want to use it, you can substitute vegetable oil instead. If you’re going with veggie oil because you want a vegetarian mole, swap in vegetable broth for the chicken stock too. Otherwise, there aren’t any changes you need to make to the recipe.

Piloncillo

This is unrefined, raw cane sugar, usually sold in molded cones, that has a dark brown color and a round, rich flavor somewhat like molasses in its complexity. You can grate piloncillo, chop it into pieces with a sharp knife, or in this case, simply add the whole cone to the pot, where it will dissolve into the sauce over the long cooking time. Its sweetness helps balance the deep earthy, spicy, and smoky flavors of the sauce.

Goya Piloncillo, 2 for $7.99 on Amazon

Also known as panela.
Buy Now

Serving Mole

You can serve mole on whatever you like, but a classic—and delicious—strategy is to make enchiladas. Just roll fresh corn tortillas around any number of fillings (roasted turkey, pulled rotisserie chicken, cooked sweet potatoes, shredded cheese, pretty much anything that sounds good to you), and then cover them generously with the mole sauce. Garnish with sesame seeds, raw slices of onion, cilantro, and, if you can get them, squash blossoms.

A little rice on the side and you’ll want for nothing more. Well, maybe a margarita after all…but try some lesser known Mexican spirits too, or a Mexican craft beer. Just be sure to raise a toast—to Puebla, and to yourself for all your hard work.

authentic mole recipe

Chowhound

Mole Casero Recipe from Casa Pública

Make this next weekend; you won’t regret it. (And to save yourself the trouble of converting amounts, get yourself a kitchen scale.)

Ingredients:

  • 1 quart chile powder
    • 50 mulato chiles
    • 35 ancho chiles
    • 25 pasilla chiles
    • 25 chipotle chiles
  • 165 grams whole, unskinned almonds
  • 150 grams sesame seeds
  • 10 grams oregano
  • 1/2 small stick cinnamon
  • 6 whole cloves
  • 4 allspice berries
  • 6 tomatillos, husks removed
  • 6 plum tomatoes
  • 3 Spanish onions, peeled and cut into wedges
  • 5 liters chicken stock
  • 225 grams nixtamal masa
  • 165 grams raisins
  • 225 grams lard (manteca)
  • 2 discs Mexican chocolate
  • salt to taste
  • 1 8-ounce cone piloncillo

Instructions:

1. Make the chile powder. Preheat the oven to 250 degrees. Remove caps and seeds from all dried chiles. Spread the chiles on sheet pans and toast in the oven for 30 minutes, until dry and crackling. Rotate pans halfway through so they toast evenly. Once toasted, allow to cool completely, then grind into a powder in a blender or food processor. Mix well and sift through a fine mesh strainer, then set aside.

2. Make the mole base. In a dry cast iron skillet over high heat, char the tomatoes, tomatillos, and onions until dark; set aside. Lower heat to medium, clean the skillet, then toast the almonds and set aside (you can put all of these cooked ingredients in the same bowl once they’re done, or just put them straight in the blender). Toast the sesame seeds and set aside. Turn heat to low and toast cinnamon, clove, allspice, and oregano; set aside. In a blender, puree the charred tomatoes, tomatillos, and onion with the toasted nuts, seeds, and spices, plus the raisins and 1 quart of chicken stock; transfer this base to a bowl and set aside.

4. Blend the masa. Clean the blender, add the masa and 1 more quart of chicken stock, then blend and set aside.

5. Bring the mole together. Heat a wide, deep pot over medium heat and melt the manteca until liquid; you want it to be hot and sizzling. Fry the chile powder, stirring constantly, until it is fully incorporated and bubbling (but be careful not to burn it). Add the reserved mole base to the pot and fry for another 5 minutes while stirring constantly. When it just starts to stick to the pot, add the masa and chicken stock blend, and the remaining 3 liters chicken stock in stages—you might not need all of the stock, and it’s best to add it slowly so your sauce doesn’t become too liquid. Add the piloncillo and Mexican chocolate. Turn the heat to low and let simmer for 2.5 – 3 hours, stirring frequently, until you have a rich, thick sauce you could polish off with nothing but a spoon. Salt to taste and remove from heat.

To serve:

Warm up tortillas with a bit of oil to make them flexible. Roll them up tightly with the filling of your preference, then bathe the rolls completely with warm mole and garnish with sesame seeds, white onion rings, cilantro, and squash blossoms (optional but super seasonal and pretty). If you use a cold filling, like cheese, warm up the rolled enchiladas in a 350 degree oven for 5 minutes before plating and saucing. Serve with white or red rice.

Shortcut Mole

If you just can’t commit to the mole-making process at the moment but you’re really craving some authentic Mexican flavor ASAP, try a mole paste as the base of your sauce.

Mole Poblano Paste, $21.45 on Amazon

For when you don't have time to start from scratch.
Buy Now

Otherwise, here’s your mole shopping list:

Mole Shopping List

Essential ingredients and tools for making mole at home

Nestle Abuelita Mexican Chocolate, $3.39 on Amazon

Try adding this to your next batch of chili too.
Buy Now

Los Chileros Mulato Chiles, 2 ounces for $5.70 on Amazon

These aren't spicy, but add complex fruity flavors to the mole.
Buy Now

Ole Mission Ancho Chiles, 16 ounces for $18.99 on Amazon

These help emphasize the earthy flavors.
Buy Now

Ole Mission Pasilla Chiles, 4 ounces for $8.53 on Amazon

Add yet another layer of flavor with these pasillas.
Buy Now

Ole Mission Chipotle Chiles, 4 ounces for $9.97 on Amazon

And bring a bit of smoky spice to the sauce with dried chipotles.
Buy Now

Goya Piloncillo, 2 for $7.99 on Amazon

Sweetness that's far from one-note.
Buy Now

Maseca Instant Corn Masa Flour, $2.88 at Walmart

For thickening your mole, and making fresh tortillas to go along with it.
Buy Now

Victoria Cast Iron Torilla Press, $24.99 on Amazon

If you do want to make your own tortillas, this is a handy tool to have.
Buy Now

Ninja Professional 1000-Watt Blender, $79.99 at Walmart

You'll definitely need a blender or food processor for making the sauce from scratch.
Buy Now

Lodge 10.25-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, $14.88 on Amazon

And a cast iron skillet is ideal for charring and toasting all your components. This one is pre-seasoned, so you can get cooking right away.
Buy Now

Ozeri Scale Pronto Digital Multifunction Kitchen Scale, $14.95 on Amazon

Measure in grams or ounces, within two decimal points for even greater accuracy.
Buy Now

Follow our Chow-To series for more lessons in great dishes from fantastic chefs, including under-the-radar Persian butter bean stew, classic French macarons, and everyone’s favorite: hummus.

All featured products are curated independently by our editors. When you buy something through our retail links, we may receive a commission. For more great hand-picked products, check out the Chowhound Shop.

Jen is an associate content producer at Chowhound. Raised on scrapple and blue crabs, she hails from Baltimore, Maryland, but has lived in Portland (Oregon) for so long it feels like home. She enjoys the rain, reads, writes, eats, and cooks voraciously, and stops to pet every stray cat she sees. Continually working on building her Gourmet magazine collection, she will never get over its cancellation. Read more of her work.
See more articles