My son got engaged erev Succot. The bride's family suggested a wedding in williamsburgh because of the price and the availability of very large halls. My daughter got married 4 years ago at Eden Roc. The food was wonderful, but I've hear that it's gone down hill since then. My younger son got married at Ateret Avraham and I heard rave reviews. But we want mixed seating, so the latter is not an option. Rose Castle and Eden Roc are the only choices if we desire some mixed seating. Does anyone have any comments or suggestions?