I am looking for a spot for about 40 people for dinner at $50 per person, including wine, tip and tax. It's a casual dinner out--no fancy celebration. Family style platters are perfect but not required. We did Tony Di Napoli last year but it was a bit of a trip from our office at Park Ave South and 26th St. Ideally, we would like to be as south as 14th and just below 42nd St. We would like to avoid the theater district. We are fine on the East side and on the West side, up to 6th Ave (7th would be stretching it). A private room is preferable or a sectioned off area. Something like Carmines/Tony Di Napoli is fine but not required. We are planning now so we can book ahead of time--before our meeting in March so options (whatever they might be) are wide open. I would probably skip Japanese/sushi or Indian as we have taste preferences from all over the country to accommodate. American is fine, Italian is fine.
Your suggestions are appreciated. Thanks.