With one thing and another, I hadn't been to Tullulah's in quite some time, certainly not since they changed around the menu a little. I've had the chance to go back a couple of times over the last few weeks, and this will go back to being a regular trip.
For me the trigger was the opening (or my discovery) of a number of "gourmet" (I use the term loosely) sandwich places: Roast in Melville, Souper Fry in Merrick, among others. I've been variously pleased and disappointed by them, and by purest happenstance have been in or near Bay Shore and remembered Tullulah's
Wow. Head and shoulders above the others. Glorious concoctions. Some of this is almost puzzling: Souper Fry advertises that their fries are hand-cut, and I know Tullulah's aren't, but the latter's truffle fries were far, far better, crisp and tasty than anything I had at SF.
I maintain a limited list of places for repeat lunch visits (reserving time for new places); Tullulah's is back on the list.
1762 Merrick Ave, Merrick, NY 11566