I can't decide. I don't have enough counter space for both! I have an old toaster oven that has slowly broken down. I mostly use it for toast, melting cheese on things (one of my favorite pastimes!) and toasting nuts. The toast never comes out so great, and I could probably use the broiler for the other things...and yet, I like having a toaster oven. I know I'm lucky if this is my biggest dilemma in life. Seriously, I've bought cars with less consideration than this!