A new ice cream shop - Sweet Anniez Ice Cream and Candy Shop - opened up on Mamaroneck Ave between Rutherford and Livingston Avenues, replacing a delicatessen. The ice cream is apparently made by a woman based in Mount Pleasant who did a lot of corporate catering.
Picked up a pint of their espresso chunk ice cream and was impressed. Smooth, not overly sweet, and the espresso flavor was subtle - it didn't hit you over the head. Definitely will try other flavors from there.
Given how saturated WP is with frozen yogurt shops - including two shops right across the street from each other on Mamaroneck Avenue! - it's nice to have an option for homemade ice cream in the city. The gelato at Iron Tomato is pretty good, but I'd hate to still have the best "option" for ice cream be Coldstone!
Updated 2 years ago | 18
Updated 21 days ago | 1
Updated 10 hours ago | 120
Updated 6 days ago | 38
Updated 1 day ago | 10