Meant to post here, with thanks. I was thinking of making an expedition from Manhattan to Eddies' Sweet Shop in search of sundaes, and when I was trying to figure out how to get there, I ran across hints that the place was no longer worth a trip, and I was detoured to Hinsch's instead.
Disappointingly shiny place. And the waitress was surprisingly flaky, considering there were one three tables occupied. But happy with my hot fudge sundae. It was a little skimpy at the price ($5.50, I think), and no embellishments, but the fudge was good (not overly sweet), and the bonus of actual, real whipped cream was decadently exciting.