After eating at this restaurant last Thursday and reading quite a few reviews, the conclusion I come to is that this place is very uneven. We went here at 6:30 because Founding Fathers had over an hour wait and we were able to walk right in to Sugo. Our food (gnocchi, raviolli stuffed with spinach, onion love pizza, calamari and ceasar salad) was not outstanding. Overall it was too salty. To me the raviolli and gnocchi were tasteless. The salad had almost no dressing on it although the romaine was fresh and crispy. I liked the flavor of the pizza but could have used a few more onions to love. The calamari was tender but the coating too thick and salty and the dollop of sauce too little especially for three people to share. Albarino, pinot noir and sangria were not especially good and not worth their prices.
Interestingly, I could find no reviews of this place on Chowhound just a mention in another post.