After many years in Brewster/Dennis/Orleans area, this year we will be staying in Provincetown, where we haven't been to have dinner in the past seven years. Used to love Chester, sadly missed, and Front Street, but need to make reservations pretty soon for Friday and Saturday in mid July, hoping some Chowhounders can help us make a couple of great choices.
We eat seafood on Cape, and look for a Chowhound type experience. Great food is first priority, we are relaxed about service, ambiance, and wine/drinks. One of us has major allergy to mushrooms and intolerance to lobster, but those are the only food restrictions, though we are very seafood oriented.
If we were still on the Lower Cape, it would be a no-brainer: Abba and Nauset Beach Club in Orleans, or Fin in Dennis, we would be happy diners. Where in Provincetown should we be heading for a similar level of satisfaction?
Victor's, Devon's, Jimmy's Hideaway, Ross' Grill, and Dalla Cucina look interesting. Any others we should consider? Good or bad to report about any of these?
We had bad experiences in the past at The Mews and Edwige, so are unlikely to go back to either of those.
We will spend a few days in Wellfleet as well, so any Truro or Wellfleet suggestions will be visited then, for now we are looking for great dinners in Provincetown.
Any recommendations will be appreciated!