Restaurants & Bars

Manhattan

Help me make sense of my Blue Hill experience?

Share:

More from Restaurants & Bars

Restaurants & Bars Manhattan

Help me make sense of my Blue Hill experience?

p
PeteM | | Nov 28, 2007 08:40 AM

I had a disappointing experience at Blue Hill recently. But instead of writing a bad review I want your input so I can make sense of my experience.

The thing is my disappointment can simply come from unreasonable / inappropriate expectations, so it can be my fault instead of Blue Hill's.

So I want your thoughts on this: What should I have been expecting from Blue Hill? Why is it so highly regarded? What do you guys like about it?

I have read every single review on Blue Hill I can find on google (some before, some after my visit), but I would really appreciate it if you guys can be as concrete as possible. Until now I have only read things like "the lamb tasted so fresh" or "the porkchop was the best ever", which I find pretty vague and not useful to ground my own experience. What does it mean for the lamb to be fresh? What made the porkchop so good?

The more particular, concrete and specific you guys are, the better I can orient my expectations and experience.

Thoughts? Let's get the discussion started!

Feedback