Going to S.I. in about a month and desperately need dining advice. While trolling through past boards, I've noticed a few names that keep on popping up - but I'd like to narrow it down to 2 criteria: 1) 'Romantic' (i.e. Cocktails without screaming kids), and 2) Relatively Quiet (being able to hold a conversation without raising your voice). My picks so far:
1) Il Tesoro (not mentioned on Chowhound, but menu looks great)
2) Mad Hatter
4) Dolce Vita
5) Sweet Melissa's
6) Greenhouse Grill
Our only experience in Fl. dining scene is Key West. Love La Trat, Santiago's, Antonia's, LaTeDa, and Square One.