I don't get Delfina. I honestly don't. I've noticed this nasty trend in San Francisco for restaurants to take Italian-American cuisine, the likes of which can be found in any deli or bodega on the East Coast, and celebrate it as if it were the Second Coming. Despite the giant lines crowing the sidewalk every day, Delfina is not remarkable and it is almost certainly not worth waiting for.
While not attempting to engage in the perennial New York versus San Francisco food debate, Delfina would never receive the accolades that it does were it in the New York area. Simply, the food is plain, unimaginative, and not even well done. I have had pizza from Delfina twice, both here on 18th St and their location near FIllmore Street. Their dough and crust is just all right, but it is their flavors where they really fall short. The pizza is bland and boring.
Delfina also does not push the definition of pizza. Nothing new, nothing unique, nothing that can only be found at Delfina. By itself, that is fine! There's nothing wrong with taking classical dishes and doing them well. But Delfina manages to make everything taste bland and boring.
So now when I see the crowds waiting for an hour for a table, I can walk on by without any regrets.
3621 18th St, San Francisco, CA 94110